Science Atlas

How We Know What We Know
Atlas Trail

How Theories Fall

7 stops

Four scientific theories replaced by better ones, and what it actually took each time: new evidence, a missing mechanism finally supplied, or a rival account that still has not been settled.

Stop 1 of 7.
Theories

Phlogiston theory organized a century of chemistry correctly, but could not explain why metals gain weight when they burn.

Stop 2 of 7.
Theories

Lavoisier's sealed-vessel measurements replaced it with oxygen theory, though Priestley, whose own experiment supplied the key fact, never accepted the reinterpretation.

Stop 3 of 7.
Theories

Wegener's continental drift had real evidence but no mechanism, and was rejected in his lifetime.

Stop 4 of 7.
Theories

Seafloor spreading supplied the missing physics, and plate tectonics confirmed Wegener's core insight decades after his death.

Stop 5 of 7.
Theories

Steady-state theory rivaled the big bang theory until the 1965 cosmic microwave background discovery, though Fred Hoyle never accepted the result.

Stop 6 of 7.
Theories

The big bang theory's prediction of the cosmic microwave background is what settled the rivalry.

Stop 7 of 7.
Theories

Quantum theory's own interpretation is the one debate here still genuinely open: Bohr's Copenhagen collapse against Everett's many-worlds branching.

Download Card

Create an account to keep this trail. Saving copies its stops into a collection of your own, which you can add to, reorder and share.

Where you have got to in this trail is kept by your own browser and is never sent to us. Clearing your browser data clears it. All trails.