Science Atlas

How We Know What We Know
Articles

Two Physicists Who Both Got There First

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Learn More
Two Physicists Who Both Got There First

In September 1945 the American physicist Edwin McMillan published a paper describing a new principle for particle accelerators. He called it phase stability: by slowly lowering the frequency of an accelerator's driving electric field as particles gained energy, the field and the particles could be kept in step indefinitely, letting a ring of modest size reach energies far beyond anything a cyclotron could manage. He called the resulting machine a synchrotron.

Within weeks McMillan learned he had been beaten to the idea, by more than a year. Vladimir Veksler, a Soviet physicist, had worked out the same principle in 1944 and published it in a Russian journal. Wartime conditions meant the paper had not reached the West, so McMillan had genuinely never seen it when he wrote his own. Once he did see it, he did the thing that priority disputes in science usually do not produce: he said so plainly, in print, crediting Veksler with getting there first.

What makes this case unusual is not that two people found the same idea independently. Multiple discovery is common enough in physics that historians have a name for it. What is unusual is the reason the two men did not know about each other's work. This was not two labs racing in parallel with full knowledge of the field. It was a wartime information blackout that hid a finished result from the entire scientific community it was intended for, for the better part of a year, purely as a side effect of the war rather than of secrecy about the physics itself.

The two men did not become rivals over it. McMillan's public acknowledgment set the tone, and by 1963 the two shared the Atoms for Peace Award for the invention jointly, an unusually clean resolution for a priority question that could easily have curdled into decades of argument. Every synchrotron built since, up to and including the Large Hadron Collider, rests on the phase stability principle they arrived at within a year of each other, from opposite sides of a wartime silence.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Article On

Sources
Edwin McMillan (Wikipedia)
WikipediaSynchrotron and phase stability sectionView the Source
Edwin McMillan (Wikipedia)
WikipediaArticle On: SynchrotronView the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.